I think we had this same question last year. Or maybe the year before. Maybe both.
See, this is what we do. When things go bad, we want somebody's hide and say, "Aha! This is what the problem is. Fix this and all will be well."
Jason Garrett calling plays is not the problem. Jason Garrett at the end of tight games has been a problem. He has let too many seconds go off the clock in three close games, and it's inexcusable given how tough it is to win the NFL and how much Garrett preaches situational football.
But taking away the play calling from Garrett does not solve that issue. It adds another layer of bureaucracy to the process. And I hate saying something like that because that's the same reason Jerry Jones uses to be the owner and general manager of this team.
There is a big difference, however. The head coach has to make decisions on the fly. The general manager is supposed to be reasoned and rational in an offseason.
If you want Garrett to lose play-calling duties, then you're under the supposition that he does nothing but think of that particular play and that particular play only. The play caller has to think of everything from the time and score, down and distance, what defensive personnel is on the field. Everything.
You also believe there was a coach on the staff reminding Garrett of the situation in the fourth quarter Sunday. Apparently there wasn't one. Or Garrett tuned that guy out. You can't guarantee me it will be better if Garrett loses the play calling, which is something I think he is pretty good at doing.
Say Garrett allowed Bill Callahan to call the plays. Do you think the head coach would stand down and not be involved? If the same situation arose Sunday and Garrett wasn't the play caller, do you think he would have said, "Now, remember, we have one timeout left, so let's not run
Miles Austin and
Kevin Ogletree down the field on vertical routes?" Just because his load was lighter on the day of games?
Sean Payton called the plays in New Orleans and succeeded. Mike McCarthy is doing the same in Green Bay. It can be done by one guy and with success. Heck, Tom Landry called the offense
and defense at times when he coached the
Cowboys.
We talk all the time about how a quarterback needs a clock in his mind to make decisions quickly or he'll take too many sacks.
Garrett needs that clock as well, to speed up his thought process in close games.
Taking away the play-calling -- especially after the Cowboys' best offensive day of the season -- doesn't solve the problem. It only might create a bigger one.